Can You Tell A Story In…

It’s that time of the week again – story challenge time.

Can you tell a story in 26 words using the following words in it somewhere:

  • ORGANIC
  • CATERPILLAR
  • SUDOKU

Last week’s challenge was to write a story in 50 words using the following five words in it somewhere:

  • POEM
  • CRITIQUE
  • MURDER
  • CUPCAKE
  • DICE

Here are your wonderful stories:

Kate in Cornwall:

Lady Ursula Plaid-Cardigan seethed as she read Penelope Pratt’s critique of her poem, ‘Ode to a Cupcake’.

‘More painful than childbirth and equally as messy’, the art critic opined.

“Vilify my verse and you dice with death,” snarled Ursula, grabbing her phone.

Police are describing Pratt’s vicious murder as ‘professional’.

Pete:

Choo Choo Mama: Roll the dice my little cupcake and I’ll recite a poem for you. If it comes up snake eyes you can give the poem a critique. But if it comes up with boxcars, I guess I’ll just have to murder you. That’s how my literary train rolls. 

Help from Heaven:

Not Everyone Understands Good Poetry

Edwin’s critique of Marla’s poem left her so mad! Remembering that some people cannot appreciate subtlety, rather than murdering a friend, she opted for a double-chocolate cupcake to comfort her. After all, poetry can be like the roll of the dice: sometimes people get it and other times they don’t.  

Christopher Farley:

“OK, listen, cupcake. My agent showed me the newspaper. I think you’d better get back to your typewriter and do something about that critique, or change your job. I never said I was Dylan Thomas but to murder my poem like that and expect me to take it? No dice.”

Graeme Sandford:

To critique a murder in a poem lacked good taste; but the ‘Cupcake Murder’ as it became known, was infamous for the Russian Roulette style killing. One of the six cupcakes was poisoned – it was an unlucky roll of the dice that led to the poisoner being the one poisoned. 

Nicola Daly:

‘I’m going to murder that bloody woman. “Critique” she calls it. Says my limerick isn’t a “proper” poem. Can’t be included in her precious anthology. Just wait, I’ll dice her bloody anthology into little cubes. See how she likes that. Pass me a cupcake, love. That’s right, the chocolate one.

Annette Rochelle-Aben:

Hot and Cross

It was the roll of the sugar cube dice that forced the authorities to arrest Julia’s child, Julie, for the murder of Shapely Sweet Cheeks a.k.a. Cupcake. Of course, she wouldn’t have smothered Shapely with fondant, had she not unfavourably critiqued Julie’s poem titled Mastering the Art of Bun Baking!

Kim Smyth:

I was writing a poem that I expected would be critiqued by the editor later. Boy, I’d like to murder her sometimes t thought as I munched on a cupcake. I’m rolling the dice that what I’ll get in the mail is another rejection letter. But that’s just my luck!

My Mind Mappings:

I threw the dice and when they came up seven, it was a sign to publish my love poem on my blog.

I ate a cupcake as I waited for the likes and comments to arrive, But the first was a harsh critique equating my poem to committing literary murder.

Pensitivity101:

The teacher’s critique opinion of my poem was heartless and cruel.

I always knew he had no sense of humour.

“Murder by Cupcake” was a tongue in cheek look at gluttony, greed and vengeance in order to secure the family inheritance. The weapon of choice proved ‘no dice’ for success.

Pictures Imperfect Blog:

“I could murder a curry,” he said. He looked over to his granddaughter, nodded with placid deference, rolled the dice, sighed deeply and stated: “A cupcake it is.”

He started to dictate a poem to Susan while chewing and added: “Don’t critique it too harshly. I’m not at my best.”

Rall:

it’s the roll of the dice if the critique is favourable or not
They steal my poems anyway so they must be OK
I found one of them in a book called The Cupcake Murder
a story about a psycho who killed his mother because she didn’t put
icing on it

Murray Clarke:

William sat down on a wooden stool, and reaching for his trusted quill and parchment, began to write a new poem. He paused to think. “What rhymes with ‘Mystique’? ” That was the question. Finally, Shakespeare scribbled: ‘Critique’. He was so pleased with himself he cried: “I could murder a cupcake!”

iMartist:

Oh, the Horror of it all

It was my turn to stand at the podium to read my poem and have it be critiqued. I was quite nervous…

“Cupcake was
her name
& murder was
her game…
with sugar and
spice and a
pair of
fuzzy dice…”

They looked at me and said, “Nope you suck. Next !”

L Wie:

The Great Cakesby

In cupcake world there is no murder. Crime is unknown, critiques don’t exist. Nobody is mean, everyone is sweet. The young and fresh ones learn the poem once told by the Great Cakesby: “When they dice up your granny, crumbles are born, so always stay canny and do not mourn”.

Christine Mallaband-brown:

Her cupcake critique was marvellous. According to the TV chef Paul Hollywood it was a delightful poem of cherry and bitter lemon. She was rewarded with a ‘Hollywood handshake’.

Unfortunately the other contestants did not approve. She was dicing with death and she was drowned in murderous creme pat sauce.

What a disaster!

showtunessal:

Jo remembered murderously critiquing to find the right words. She rolled the dice while munching a cupcake and considered not giving him the poem. They were only 13.

Umbrella
Under the Umbrella with YOU
Skies are always Blue.
My first kiss under the Dome
You promised you’d always be True.

Silly Frog’s Blog:

The captain was a hard ass.

My murder-scene critique was met with,

“Big mistake, you, naive cupcake! Seems I lost the roll of the dice, Newbie.”

“Captain…You investigating or writing a poem?”

He grinned and slapped my back.

“Look at the ceiling, again. That’s not knife castoff. It’s ketchup!”

John W. Howell:

When he appeared before a panel of judges for a critique of his poem, the gangster-looking guy reached into his breast pocket for a cupcake. The gesture was taken as a threat. No one wanted to roll the dice that a bad word wouldn’t mean murder.

Teleportingweena:

I rolled the dice and took a chance on winning a cupcake prize for my little poem. However, the judges were harsh and murdered my verse with a snort, a laugh, and a big fat no critique.

My eye spies the prize

The cupcake will be mine?

I didn’t win

Let’s Write:

Slam-dunk

At the poetry slam, Aureliana’s poem, ‘The Cupcake Murder’ shocked everyone.

‘No – far too dicey,’ critiqued the compare.

‘But it was heartfelt,’ shouted Aureliana.

Laughter erupted when she threw a cupcake right in his face.

The cupcake survived, but the gathering turned chaotic. Who knew fancies could be so deadly?

Lily’s Corner:

Following Clues

I pulled out the poem from between the crevices where the murder took place that would give me a clue to the treasure. Hmm, not very good, but enough with my ill-timing critique.

“Walk 10 paces down,
go all around the cupcake store,
beneath the steps; dice.”

Here I go!

Therapy Bits:

The poet baked a cupcake for his muse, sweet as his latest poem.

Her critique sliced deeper than knives.

Anger rolled through him like loaded dice—chance gone rogue.

When dawn came, the frosting was red, the verse complete.

They called it passion.

The police called it murder.

Dawgy Daddy Responds:

This Poem

Roll the dice and critique this poem

It’s time again for the witches ball
A cackle goes out for one and all
The full moon will drive you crazy
The witches skirts flimsy and lacy
Will you answer the Halloween call

Listen up cupcake, murder is committed for a price.

Richmond Road:

Not a murder-mystery
Not a real poem
Not for rhythm, not for rhyme
No plot-twists here to throw ‘em
Just a little cupcake
Not naughty, maybe nice
Literary gamble
Played with loaded dice
Hardly an original.
Don’t think it’s unique
Please feel free to read it
But thank-you. No critique.

Treehugger:

My attempt at a poem,

The bake of her cupcake,

Unfortunately made my jaws ache.

But expressing my critique,

Made my outlook very bleak.

So with death I did dice,

As she hurled the block of ice.

With my murder in her mind,

A safe refuge I needed to find.

The Elephant’s Trunk:

Fit of Rage

The harsh critique of a murder mystery poem led to a heated argument. In a fit of rage, the poet grabbed a cupcake and threw it at the critic. The cupcake missed, hitting a shelf of dice instead. The noisy tumbling dice brought an abrupt end to the poetic showdown.

Ann Edall-Robson:

Dr. Cupcake tossed the ornate dice across the table. The result would guide his decision whether to destroy or keep the notes linked to his latest poem. Someone in the writing critique group was more than determined that he was guilty of the murder he had written about. Snake Eyes!

Utahan15:

a poem

this tome

has a home

killin murder done in

slim slope

chocolate cupcake i hope

your critique is in line

***

57 responses to “Can You Tell A Story In…”

  1. nikidaly70 Avatar
    nikidaly70

    After a leisurely morning completing the ‘Times’ suduko, Colin the Caterpillar had a snooze and then crawled to his vegetable patch to tend his organic cabbages.

    Liked by 8 people

      1. nikidaly70 Avatar
        nikidaly70

        Yeah, it’s a caterpillar’s life 🤣

        Liked by 2 people

    1. To eat them, I assume.

      Liked by 3 people

      1. nikidaly70 Avatar
        nikidaly70

        if he’s anything like the caterpillars on my organic cabbages …🤣

        Liked by 2 people

  2. […] Daily writing promptWhen you think of the word “successful,” who’s the first person that comes to mind and why?View all responses https://worddaily.com/ https://estherchilton.co.uk/2025/10/16/can-you-tell-a-story-in-309/ […]

    Liked by 4 people

    1. Hi for some reason I can’t leave a comment on your site – I liked your little story – I found it hard this week too!

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Not a happy little vegemite today. Found a caterpillar in my organic salad and I read that science has discovered that sudoku players are unimaginative simpletons

    Liked by 8 people

    1. That’s hilarious. I’d better not tell my mother then, who is an avid sudoko player 😂😂

      Liked by 1 person

  4. […] words for a 26-word story – this week’s challenge for Esther Chilton’s „Can you tell a story“ […]

    Liked by 3 people

  5. […] Can You Tell A Story In… […]

    Liked by 2 people

  6. The caterpillar crawled across the Suduko square in an organic way.

    Suddenly, a butterfly emerged, the magic result of completing the puzzle. It fluttered away happily.

    Liked by 7 people

    1. I do love a happy ending ❤️

      Liked by 2 people

  7. […] for Can You Tell A Story In #309 from Esther Chilton. The prompts are “Caterpillar,” “Sudoku,” and […]

    Liked by 2 people

  8. ‘Despite vegetables being good for the brain,’ said the caterpillar, eating a leaf of organic kale, ‘I still can’t work out how to play this Sudoko.’

    Liked by 7 people

    1. That left with a smile, Chris 😊

      Liked by 2 people

  9. Reconciling my checkbook was an unpleasant sudoku puzzle back in the day. I would load up the hookah with organic caterpillar and smoke cipher woes away.

    Liked by 5 people

    1. You’ve thought outside the box there, Pete.

      Liked by 2 people

      1. 🤣 Nice one E.C. 🤣

        Liked by 2 people

  10. My pet caterpillar is fed only organic jasmine leaves which is why he is a big help at finalizing my Suduko puzzle.

    Liked by 7 people

    1. Glad to hear it, John 😂

      Liked by 2 people

  11. […] Can You Tell A Story In… – Esther Chilton […]

    Liked by 2 people

  12. […] her “Can You Tell a Story In…” prompt today, Esther Chilton has challenged us to tell a 26-word story using the words organic, […]

    Liked by 2 people

  13. […] afternoon, hope you all are doing well this fine autumn day. This is my submission for Esther Chilton‘s writing prompt for this […]

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Really enjoy it 🥰

      Liked by 1 person

  14. […] for Esther’s “Can You Tell A Story In” –#309 in exactly 26 words using these fiveprompt words: ‘organic’, ‘caterpillar’, […]

    Liked by 1 person

    1. So funny, Nancy. Thank you 🥰

      Liked by 2 people

      1. Thanks very much, Esther.

        Liked by 2 people

  15. It’s 26 twice (ok – so I cheated).

    ON MATTERS OF LIFE AND DEATH

    Sitting in the morning sun
    Doing the Sudoku
    A caterpillar in a tree
    Gets eaten by a cuckoo

    PART TWO

    It goes to show, that’s how things go
    When everything’s botanic
    Round the bend, that’s how things trend
    In the end we’re all organic

    THE END

    Liked by 5 people

    1. I love them so I’ll let you off 😊

      Liked by 1 person

      1. The fact is that I’m a bit obsessed with cuckoos at present. We have a little house by the river and at this time of year (Spring) there’s a lovesick cuckoo who shows up, trying to win a bride. He does this by screaming at the top of his voice. I have to give him points for persistence, though. Back in the day, when my own smooth talking and disarming good looks let me down (frequently), I’d head home for a cold shower and a cup of tea. But this dude seems to be able to keep it up (pun vaguely intended) all night. It’s driving me crazy.
        I don’t speak cuckoo (it’s all Greek to me) but I’m imagining that some of the stuff he comes out with at around 4AM is fairly ribald, because that’s when he’s at his loudest.
        I don’t know what a lady cuckoo sounds like but I’m rather hoping to hear one whisper, to this suitor, something to the effect of, “why don’t you just shut the fuck up and come to bed?”
        Anyway …. I had to get the word Cuckoo down on the page and out of my head. It took 52 words (not 26) to exorcise the demon.

        Liked by 2 people

      2. I feel for you – we have a noisy owl, who starts up as soon as it’s dark, but he at least gives us a break now and then. I’ve never heard the cuckoo sound and I’m presuming it’s far more annoying than the gentle hoot of an owl.

        Liked by 1 person

      3. I don’t want to bore you with this, but …..
        The cuckoo sound is definitely not a hoot. Once or twice would be ok – rather sweet, in fact, but two or three hundred in a row begins to bore holes in your brain.

        Apparently though, the way to get rid of them is to play cuckoo sounds back to them – they don’t like opposition evidently, or are just very respectful of others’ territory.
        The community we live in by the river is very small – about 40 houses in all, so news of the cuckoo dispersement technique spread quickly with several houses trying it.

        So it occurs to me that the actual cuckoo might be long gone, and what I am hearing is two or three different households playing cuckoo sounds to each other.

        Liked by 2 people

      4. You’ve not bored me at all. I think this is fascinating and yes, you may just be hearing your neighbours!

        Liked by 1 person

  16. squirreljan Avatar
    squirreljan

    The caterpillar entered the Sudoku maze, numbered gates opening as he wriggled through correctly. Finally, he reached the grass. Yuk – humongous effort and it wasn’t organic.

    Liked by 4 people

    1. After all that effort too! Fun story 😊

      Liked by 1 person

  17. As I watched the caterpillar munching on my organic cabbages, I resisted reaching for the bug tweezers and sat on the swing, calmly solving my Sudoku puzzle .

    Liked by 3 people

    1. That made me laugh out loud, Thanks, Sheila.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Thank you .I do have a problem with caterpillars .Perhaps I should listen to my story’s advice.

        Liked by 2 people

  18. […] Esther’s story challenge for this week is to write a tale in exactly 26 words using the following: ORGANIC; CATERPILLAR & SUDOKU – now I found this quite a task! 🐛https://estherchilton.co.uk/2025/10/16/can-you-tell-a-story-in-309/ […]

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a reply to Can You Tell A Story In …? | teleportingweena Cancel reply

Discover more from Esther Chilton

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading